Everyone Wants Experienced Aviation Professionals. Who Is Going to Create Them?
Boeing's 2026 Pilot and Technician Outlook estimates that commercial aviation will need approximately 674,000 new pilots and 728,000 new maintenance technicians over the next 20 years. Including cabin crew, the forecast exceeds 2.4 million new aviation professionals, with roughly two-thirds of the requirement driven by replacement rather than fleet growth. The scale is substantial, but the more important issue is hidden inside the word "new": aviation does not simply need to recruit millions of people. It has to create enough professionals who are qualified, experienced and capable of performing independently in operational environments.
That distinction becomes increasingly important as employers compete for people who are already productive. An airline needing captains can recruit them from another airline, an MRO can hire licensed engineers from a competitor, and a training organisation can attract experienced instructors from an operator. Each employer may improve its own position, but the total amount of experienced capability available to aviation has not increased.

Published: 20 November 2026
Written by: Todd Skaggs
The industry therefore faces a deeper workforce problem than talent acquisition. Creating a capable professional takes money, training capacity, experienced instructors, operational exposure and, above all, time. Yet the organisation paying those costs may not be the organisation that ultimately employs the person for most of their career.
That creates the Capability Creator's Dilemma. Aviation needs organisations willing to invest in producing experienced professionals, but a competitive labour market allows the value created by that investment to move between employers. If the economics of creation become unattractive, every company can remain rational individually while the industry collectively produces too few people.
Aviation's Next Workforce Shortage Begins Years Before the Vacancy Appears
Workforce shortages are most visible when an organisation cannot fill vacancies, but by that point the underlying problem may already be several years old. A commercial pilot, licensed aircraft engineer, instructor, examiner or senior technical specialist is not created when a vacancy appears. The process begins much earlier with attraction, selection and initial education, followed by formal training, qualification, supervised practice, operational exposure and progression through increasingly responsible work.
Different occupations have different pathways, but they share one important characteristic: capability accumulates over time. IATA's 2026 economic outlook describes persistent shortages of pilots, engineers and technical staff as a structural constraint and identifies long training pipelines as part of the problem. The US Government Accountability Office has similarly noted that becoming a commercial airline pilot requires years of training and experience, while its examination of the post-pandemic regional pilot market showed why increasing the number of junior pilots did not immediately resolve shortages of captains.
Vacancy data are therefore a lagging indicator. An airline can discover in 2032 that it lacks experienced captains because too few people entered or progressed through the relevant stages in 2027. An MRO can face a shortage of certifying engineers years after decisions were made about apprenticeship numbers, mentoring capacity or the amount of developmental work junior employees received.
Aircraft fleet planning already recognises this principle. Airlines order aircraft years before they need the capacity because long delivery lead times make it commercially impossible to wait until the requirement becomes urgent. Human capability with similarly long development cycles deserves comparable planning discipline, because a workforce shortage that becomes visible today may have been created by decisions made several budget cycles earlier.
The strategic question is therefore not simply how many people aviation needs in twenty years. Leadership also needs to know whether enough people are entering the pathways today, whether sufficient training and development capacity exists to move them through those pathways, and whether organisations have a strong enough economic reason to make that investment.
The Capability Creator's Dilemma
Imagine a smaller aviation organisation that recruits apprentices or early-career professionals, pays for training, provides experienced mentors and gives them the operational exposure through which they become increasingly productive. Several years later those employees possess exactly the combination of qualifications and experience that larger employers are willing to pay a premium to acquire.
The larger employer has done nothing improper by recruiting them, and the professional has done nothing improper by accepting a better opportunity. Labour mobility is one of the mechanisms through which people improve their careers, compensation and working conditions, while stronger employment propositions are rewarded in the market. The issue is not movement itself.
The problem appears when the organisation creating capability cannot capture enough of the economic value generated by its investment to justify creating the next cohort. The employee gains portable career capital, future employers gain access to a more experienced professional, and the wider industry benefits from a larger qualified workforce.
If the original employer bears most of the cost but captures too little of the return, underinvestment in development can become economically rational even when training more people would benefit aviation as a whole. That is the Capability Creator's Dilemma.
A version of this dynamic became visible in the US regional pilot market after the pandemic. The GAO found that larger network and low-cost airlines addressed their own pilot vacancies partly by recruiting from regional airlines. Those departures contributed to regional captain shortages, which in turn constrained aircraft utilisation and regional services because experienced pilots were moving upwards through the system faster than the lower parts of the pipeline could replace them.
This is not an argument against progression. Regional airlines have historically provided important experience from which pilots have advanced, just as smaller maintenance organisations, independent operators and specialist companies can provide developmental environments from which people later move into larger employers.
The strategic question is whether aviation has designed an economic system in which organisations remain willing to perform that developmental role. If one company bears the cost of creating expertise while another can acquire the finished capability through a higher salary, the first company needs to believe that the productive value it receives before the employee leaves, combined with the broader benefits of its development programme, still justifies the investment. If too many employers eventually conclude that buying experience is economically preferable to creating it, aviation has a creation problem.
Training Is Not the Same as Creating Capability
The industry should also be careful about equating training numbers with workforce capacity. Completing a course, gaining a licence or entering an occupation can be an essential milestone without representing the end of capability development. Aviation depends heavily on experience accumulated after formal training, particularly where people need to exercise judgement independently under real operational conditions.
A newly qualified pilot is not immediately interchangeable with an experienced captain. A technician completing initial training is not equivalent to a certifying engineer holding the right aircraft type, recency, company authorisations and operational experience. An instructor or examiner may possess the required qualification while still building the breadth of judgement that comes from encountering unusual situations repeatedly over many years.
Aviation can therefore increase the number of people entering training while still failing to produce enough people at the experience levels where the real bottleneck exists. Capability creation should be understood as the entire journey from potential to independently deployable expertise, with recruitment, training, qualification, supervision and operational exposure forming different parts of the same development process.
Boards looking fifteen or twenty years ahead should consequently be interested not only in how many people enter a pipeline, but how many successfully progress through each critical stage, how long that progression takes and where the bottlenecks sit. A workforce pipeline that attracts thousands of entrants but cannot produce enough instructors, examiners, licensed specialists or experienced leaders is not necessarily healthy.
The Most Important Bottleneck May Be the Person Creating Other People
One reason workforce pipelines can expand more slowly than demand is that people themselves are part of the production system. Pilots require instructors, training captains and examiners, while developing engineers need experienced colleagues capable of supervising work, transferring technical knowledge and signing off competence. Specialist technical professions often depend on relatively small populations of authorised people who can assess, mentor or qualify those following behind them.
That creates an economic tension inside day-to-day operations. An experienced professional taken away from productive work to train somebody else can appear less efficient in a short-term departmental budget because part of their working time is being used to create somebody else's future output. Yet that interpretation misses the multiplier effect.
An experienced professional who only performs today's work contributes their own productive capacity. An experienced professional who also develops several colleagues contributes to today's operation while increasing tomorrow's available capability. In some circumstances, the most strategically valuable engineer may not be the one completing the greatest amount of maintenance personally, but the engineer whose knowledge and authority allow several developing employees to become independently useful.
The US pilot pipeline illustrates why these multiplier roles matter. Training throughput depends not simply on attracting candidates but on the instructors, examiners, training infrastructure and authorised people required to move those candidates through the system. Protecting instructor, examiner, mentor and supervisory capacity can therefore be just as important as protecting the frontline workforce itself.
This deserves more attention in workforce planning because capability creators can become hidden single points of failure. An organisation may have many junior candidates entering the pipeline but still be constrained by a very small number of people capable of turning them into qualified, productive professionals.
The Economics of Creation Are Difficult
Producing aviation professionals can require substantial financial investment before the individual becomes fully productive. European Flight Academy currently lists basic commercial pilot training costs in Germany at €130,000 and offers financing mechanisms intended to reduce the immediate barrier for students. British Airways has taken a different approach for selected candidates through its Speedbird Pilot Academy, while easyJet operates a fully funded aeronautical engineering apprenticeship combining formal training with practical experience.
These models allocate the cost and risk of capability creation differently. In the European Flight Academy model, the individual and financing system carry substantial responsibility; in employer-funded programmes, the company assumes considerably more of the initial cost in return for creating a direct pipeline into its future workforce.
Neither model automatically solves the wider problem. Self-funded training can restrict the available talent pool if large upfront costs deter capable candidates who cannot access finance, while employer-funded development exposes the company to the possibility that people will later take the capability it helped create elsewhere. Education creates portable value, and that portability is one of the reasons development is attractive to individuals in the first place.
The answer cannot be expecting professionals to remain indefinitely with the organisation that first trained them. A pilot, engineer or technician develops a career rather than becoming an asset owned by an employer, and mobility remains fundamental to a functioning labour market. The more useful question is whether capability creation can still make economic sense after normal employee movement is included in the model.
That changes the way employers should think about return on development. Rather than expecting certainty from every individual, companies can assess programmes across cohorts and over realistic time horizons. Some people will remain, some will leave earlier than expected, others may return later with broader experience, and some will become instructors, managers or technical authorities whose contribution far exceeds the original investment.
The relevant question is therefore not whether an employer can guarantee that every person stays. It is whether developing the population creates sufficient productive, strategic and resilience value to justify continuing the programme despite normal mobility.
Aviation Is Competing for Talent Before It Enters the Industry
There is another constraint upstream of training capacity: aviation first has to persuade capable people to choose the industry at all.
For generations, commercial aviation benefited from an attraction that extended beyond salary. Airlines, aircraft and international travel were widely associated with technological progress, prestige and ambitious careers. Aviation could draw people who actively wanted to become pilots, engineers and technical specialists because the industry itself was part of the attraction.
That advantage cannot simply be assumed today. A technically gifted student considering engineering, software, data science or advanced manufacturing can choose between aviation and sectors including artificial intelligence, space technology, advanced engineering, motorsport and high-growth technology companies that may appear closer to the frontier of innovation. These sectors are not merely competing for experienced aviation employees. They are competing for people before those people have chosen a professional identity.
This creates a different form of capability loss. If an experienced aerospace engineer moves from one aviation employer to another, the capability remains within aviation. If a talented engineering graduate chooses AI, Formula 1, space technology or another sector instead of aviation, the individual may never enter aviation's capability pipeline in the first place.
The consequence is that workforce planning cannot begin with the number of people applying for aviation jobs. It has to begin earlier with the attractiveness of aviation relative to the other industries competing for the same talent.
Pay matters, but so do perceptions of technological ambition, career progression, working conditions, flexibility and the opportunity to work on problems that talented people consider important. An industry can possess fascinating engineering challenges while failing to communicate them effectively to the people it needs to attract.
This is particularly significant because weakening attraction compounds the Capability Creator's Dilemma. Aviation can invest in more training capacity, instructors and developmental pathways, but those systems still require sufficiently capable people who want to enter them. A shrinking or less competitive pool at the beginning of the pipeline eventually becomes a shortage of experienced professionals at the other end.
The strategic question is therefore not only whether aviation is creating enough professionals from the people already entering the industry. It is whether enough of the people aviation most needs to attract and develop are choosing aviation in the first place.
Smaller Organisations Cannot Become the Industry's Unpaid Training Department
This issue becomes particularly important when different parts of the aviation ecosystem have very different abilities to pay. A major airline, OEM or large MRO may be able to offer compensation, benefits and career opportunities that a smaller company cannot realistically match. If smaller organisations perform a disproportionate share of early-career development while larger employers predominantly recruit from the experienced population they produce, the system remains stable only while those smaller organisations continue to see enough value in training.
At that point, the market begins consuming capability faster than it is producing it. An airline would be concerned if every manufacturer wanted finished components while investment in the factories producing those components was steadily declining, and human capability deserves similar attention. The industry cannot indefinitely purchase experience from a production system that is not replenishing itself.
Boards should therefore understand where the experienced people in their workforce plans are expected to come from. If every airline's five-year strategy assumes that competitors, regional carriers, MROs, military organisations, training providers or overseas markets will supply ready-made professionals, the combined assumptions may be impossible because the market cannot provide everybody with somebody else's experienced people.
Aviation Needs to Price Creation as Capacity Investment
One reason organisations underinvest in development is that its cost is visible immediately while much of its value appears later and across different budgets. Training has a direct price, instructor time has a direct price, productive employees removed from normal work to mentor others have an opportunity cost, and developing professionals may initially require more supervision while producing less output than experienced colleagues.
The benefits are harder to capture in a single line of a departmental budget. Future vacancies may be avoided, recruitment dependency can fall, succession becomes stronger, overtime pressure may reduce and the organisation gains people already familiar with its systems and culture. Internal progression can also strengthen the employee proposition because candidates can see a credible route from entry-level employment towards more skilled and responsible roles.
Management therefore needs to understand the cost of creating independently deployable capability, not simply the cost of delivering training. That means knowing how many people enter a programme, how many complete it, how long progression takes, what instructor and supervisory resources are consumed, how many become fully useful and how long the organisation typically retains their productive contribution.
Those economics can then be compared with external recruitment over a realistic time horizon. Buying experience may still be the correct choice in many situations because a company opening a new base next year cannot wait five years for every required specialist to develop internally. Growth will often require a mixture of experienced recruitment and longer-term creation.
The danger lies in treating external recruitment as though the experienced labour market were an unlimited resource available at a predictable price. It is not, and the more employers depend on the same external pool, the more fragile that assumption becomes.
Capability Creation May Need More Co-Investment
The Capability Creator's Dilemma becomes particularly difficult when the organisation paying to create capability does not capture all of the resulting economic value. That is one reason aviation may need to think more deliberately about where shared interests justify shared investment.
The industry already uses several models. Airlines fund cadet schemes and apprenticeships, individuals finance professional training, governments support education, training organisations provide infrastructure and financial institutions provide specialist lending. Each approach distributes the cost, risk and return differently.
Wider co-investment can make sense where the benefits extend beyond one employer. An airport region facing shortages of specialised engineering capability, for example, benefits when more people are trained even if those individuals eventually work for several different organisations within the local ecosystem. Airlines, MROs, training providers, educational institutions and public bodies may all capture part of the resulting economic value.
Any collaboration needs careful legal design and must not restrict employee mobility, coordinate salaries or weaken legitimate competition. The opportunity lies instead in areas such as training infrastructure, educational pathways, outreach and common foundational capability where expanding the total pool benefits multiple organisations while leaving individuals free to choose where they work.
If capability creation produces value across an ecosystem, financing it entirely through whichever organisation happens to employ the trainee on day one may not always be the most durable model.
Recruitment Must Distinguish Between Finding Capability and Creating It
Recruitment also needs to become more explicit about the difference between market supply and capability creation. A recruiter can search harder, approach passive candidates, widen geography, improve remuneration intelligence and help an employer reach people it could not reach alone. Those activities create real value when appropriate capability exists somewhere in the accessible labour market.
Recruitment cannot, however, manufacture experience that does not exist. If ten employers each brief recruitment companies to find five experienced specialists while the accessible market contains only twenty suitable people, the problem is no longer primarily recruitment performance. It is capability supply.
Specialist aviation recruiters should therefore be prepared to tell employers when the specification they want is becoming structurally scarce, when compensation is insufficient to move people, when several competitors are pursuing the same population and when a workforce plan requires development as well as acquisition.
That moves recruitment intelligence earlier in the strategic process. Instead of being asked only, "Can you find us fifty people?", the more useful conversation becomes, "Do fifty people with this capability exist in the accessible market, what will it take to attract them, and what should we start developing now because the market will not reliably supply them later?"
A difficult recruitment campaign may indicate a poor hiring proposition, but in other cases it signals a deeper shortage that cannot be solved by searching the market more aggressively.
Technology Will Not Remove the Need to Create Experience
Artificial intelligence and automation will change the amount and type of human work required across aviation, and in some functions they may allow experienced professionals to handle considerably more output. That could reduce certain forms of labour demand, but it does not eliminate the need to create expertise.
Technology can make an experienced professional more productive while increasing the importance of their underlying judgement. If fewer people supervise increasingly capable systems, aviation may become more dependent on ensuring those people possess enough domain knowledge to recognise when technology is wrong, incomplete or operating outside normal assumptions.
There is also a developmental question. If AI performs more of the routine work through which junior professionals have historically accumulated experience, employers may need to recreate those learning opportunities deliberately through mentoring, simulation and structured operational exposure.
Software capability can sometimes be deployed across an organisation within months. Producing a highly experienced captain, engineer, instructor or technical authority may still require years, so future workforce planning needs to test whether the redesigned operating model continues to create the people it will eventually depend upon.
The Board Should Ask Where Its Future Experienced People Will Come From
Most long-term workforce plans contain assumptions about external recruitment, and that is reasonable because no large aviation company will create every capability it requires entirely inside its own organisation. The assumptions become dangerous when they are not tested against the wider market.
If a fleet plan requires 200 additional experienced professionals over five years, leadership should understand how many are expected to come from internal progression, how many from external recruitment and where those external people are likely to be working today. The next question is what happens if every major competitor has made essentially the same assumption.
Boards routinely challenge assumptions around aircraft availability, financing, fuel, demand, maintenance capacity and supplier performance. The availability of experienced human capability deserves the same treatment because a recruitment plan is not a complete workforce strategy if it assumes the market will manufacture experienced people on demand.
Leadership should also identify which parts of the organisation consistently create capability. Which teams consistently turn junior people into independently deployable professionals? Which instructors, managers and experienced employees enable that progression, and where has development slowed because the people capable of mentoring others are already fully occupied delivering today's operation?
Those questions reveal something headcount alone cannot. They show whether the organisation is merely consuming experience or actively replenishing it.
Aviation Has to Make Creating People Worthwhile
The workforce challenge ahead will not be solved by asking every employer to become a training organisation. Companies have different roles, economics and capabilities, and external recruitment will remain an essential part of aviation labour markets.
The industry does, however, need enough organisations willing to develop professionals rather than simply compete for those already experienced. That requires a workable economic proposition for employers, accessible pathways for candidates, sufficient instructor and examiner capacity, sensible mechanisms for financing expensive development and a labour market in which professionals remain free to progress.
Boeing's forecast of more than 1.4 million new pilots and maintenance technicians through 2045 is therefore not simply a prediction about how many vacancies aviation companies will advertise. It represents an enormous requirement for selection, education, training, supervision, examination, qualification, mentoring and operational experience, all of which must occur somewhere before those people become the professionals employers want to recruit.
Aviation should continue competing vigorously for experienced people because competition rewards skill, improves careers and encourages employers to offer stronger opportunities. But competition can redistribute only capability that somebody has already created. Today's development expenditure is therefore part of tomorrow's operational capacity, even when some of the people an organisation develops eventually take that capability elsewhere.
The future workforce shortage will therefore begin long before airlines and MROs discover that vacancies cannot be filled. It will begin when too few employers, candidates and institutions conclude that investing in the next generation of aviation professionals is economically worthwhile. By the time the vacancy appears, the decision that created the shortage may already be several years old.
The strategic question for aviation leadership is no longer merely where experienced people will come from, but who is creating them in the first place. Boards also need to ask whether aviation is creating enough places for those people to develop, and whether the organisations doing that work still have a reason to continue.
Key Facts
Boeing's 2026 Pilot and Technician Outlook forecasts demand for approximately 674,000 new pilots and 728,000 new maintenance technicians over the next 20 years.
Including cabin crew, commercial aviation is expected to require more than 2.4 million new professionals globally.
Around two-thirds of projected workforce demand is expected to come from replacement needs rather than aviation growth.
Recruiting experienced professionals does not increase total industry capability if those professionals are simply moving between employers.
The article introduces the concept of the Capability Creator's Dilemma, where organisations investing in development may not capture all of the value they create.
Long workforce-development cycles mean that shortages often begin years before vacancies become visible.
Training, licensing and recruitment are only part of capability creation; operational exposure, supervision and progression are equally important.
Instructor, examiner, mentor and supervisory roles can become critical bottlenecks within workforce pipelines.
Aviation competes with sectors such as artificial intelligence, software, advanced engineering, motorsport and space technology for technically skilled people.
Organisations should distinguish between acquiring capability from the market and creating new capability through long-term development.
Artificial intelligence may increase productivity but does not remove the need to develop experience, judgement and operational expertise.
Workforce strategy should focus not only on where experienced people can be recruited from but also on who is creating them and whether that creation model remains economically sustainable.
Related Articles
Planning growth, fleet changes or seasonal operations in 2026? Contact Brookfield to discuss your staffing and consultancy needs. Email: info@brookfieldav.com
Explore our full range of recruitment services, connecting aviation businesses with skilled pilots, aircraft engineers and industry professionals worldwide.
Author: Todd Skaggs Aviation staffing and consultancy insights LinkedIn



















